I bought both the brown and black liners and love them. This is the first time that a liner has proven to be watered proof and stays on all day. I am older and don't want to look like I'm melting away. The liner is soft to use on older skin and really gives more definition to my eyes. Thank you.

I’ve been looking for an eyeliner that doesn’t melt away within minutes of application or doesn’t cover the lower lid waterline evenly! I bought the brown color for a somewhat softer effect ( I’m 72 years old with blonde hair) and was so disappointed when I applied it and it barely coated my skin. Maybe black would have worked better! Dunno!

So smooth! And it really does last all day, and stays in place. I use it on my waterline and once it has set, there's no smearing whatsoever. Really great product.

Disappointed. This liner does smudge, both under the eye (waterline) and above. It was advertised as a "no smudge guarantee". I am Native American/Latina and I use black liner to get enhance my eyes and to match my complexion. This smudges within two hours. Very disappointed.gave it to my daughter. Don't waste your money