I’m giving this 5 stars because the formula is chefs kiss and these lip treatments are some of the best, this confetti cake also smells delicious. The only thing I would note before purchasing is that it is REALLY purple. Not my ideal lip shade, but the formula is there. My holy grail is the clear version of this, which smells so amazing btw, so I wanted to love this one but it is just very pigmented, which for me is not what I was expecting as the other colors are a bit more sheer (my preference). But if you love purple with pinky undertones I would recommend!! It smells SO good as well, color just wasn’t for me, but I LOVE tower 28 in general and would recommend if you’re looking for one of the best lip products on the market!