I have bought this lip liner time and time again. It never fails me. I absolutely love this nude shade it’s the perfect color for a natural look while still accentuating your look. I’ve gotten three of these lip liners and I’m never going back. It’s the absolute perfect shade and it smells like chocolate. Comes out creamy and smooth. Only thing is that I have noticed I run out quickly but that may just be user error and it doesn’t last as long as I’d hope but again may just be user error. Anyways love this liner.